The family connection came before the negligence question
Issue -
October - 2026, Posted On: 01 October 2026
When a doctor treats a close relative, the relationship may appear personal, but if allegations of medical negligence arise later, the law first asks a different question: was this even a consumer dispute? In a recent decision, the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission held that the answer depended not on the surgery, but on whether the treatment had been rendered for consideration.
The complainant underwent a laparoscopic procedure performed by a doctor who happened to be her close relative. Alleging negligence during treatment, she initially succeeded before the District Consumer Forum, which awarded compensation. However, the doctor challenged the order, arguing that he had treated a family member without charging any professional fee and that no consumer-service provider relationship existed between them.
|